Or how I started a doctorate and discovered that apparently, I know nothing.
I’ve spent years working in higher education. I’m a Principal Fellow of the Higher Education Academy, a senior academic developer and Deputy Head of a Centre for Excellence in Learning and Teaching. I support academics with their teaching practice, contribute to institutional strategy and occasionally find myself in meetings where people expect me to have reasonably intelligent things to say.
And generally, I do.
Then, in September, I started an EdD.
Suddenly, I’m sitting there wondering whether everyone else understands what’s going on or whether we’re all just nodding convincingly.
It’s a strange feeling, going from being someone who knows a thing or two to someone who has just Googled the difference between ontology and epistemology. Again.
Welcome to doctoral study, apparently.
I had a plan. It was a lovely plan.
Before starting my doctorate, I had a research proposal. It had a title, research questions, a methodology and everything. I’d spent time thinking about it, and I was rather pleased with myself.
I knew what I wanted to research. I even had a reading list.
How adorable.
A few weeks later, I’ve changed my research questions several times, reconsidered the population I’m studying, questioned my theoretical assumptions and developed an increasingly complicated relationship with Zotero.
Every time I finish reading an article, I find another three I apparently must read.
At this point, I’m fairly convinced academic literature reproduces overnight.
And the research questions? I’ve started treating them like temporary house guests. Lovely to have around, but I’m not getting too attached.
The funniest part is my professor’s reaction. After I sent him yet another collection of questions, concerns and possible directions, he responded with what he described as a “HUGE GRIN”, seemingly delighted that I was asking all these questions just weeks into my doctorate.
I was having a minor intellectual crisis.
He was practically celebrating.
I suppose that’s the difference between someone who has supervised doctoral researchers for years and someone who is still trying to establish whether her research question is going to survive until Friday.
Excuse me, I’m supposed to be the experienced one
This is where things become particularly entertaining.
At work, I’m comfortable facilitating conversations about pedagogy, assessment, inclusion and academic practice. I can challenge assumptions, work through complicated institutional issues and help colleagues think critically about their teaching.
I’ve spent years encouraging people to reflect, experiment, question established practices and embrace uncertainty.
Then I become a student again, and suddenly uncertainty feels considerably less charming.
It’s easy to tell someone that learning involves stepping outside their comfort zone.
It’s rather different when you’re the one standing outside it, wondering who locked the door.
One minute I’m discussing policy development with colleagues. The next, I’m reading something on phenomenology and wondering whether I’ve misunderstood the entire philosophical foundation of my proposed research.
I have a doctorate to complete, a full-time leadership role and an impressive ability to turn one straightforward research question into approximately seventeen further questions.
Some might call that intellectual curiosity.
Others might suggest I need a hobby.
Am I experiencing impostor phenomenon, or do I just need another cup of tea?
There’s an added layer of irony here because my doctoral research explores impostor phenomenon and leadership identity among South Asian women in higher education.
Yes, I chose to research the very thing that occasionally makes me question whether I know what I’m doing.
You really couldn’t make it up.
But I’ve been thinking carefully about something.
When I encounter an unfamiliar theory or struggle to make sense of an academic argument, is that an impostor experience? Am I questioning whether I belong in doctoral education? Or am I doing exactly what a doctoral student is supposed to do?
I don’t think we should be too quick to label every moment of uncertainty as impostor phenomenon.
Sometimes we’re uncertain because we’re learning something difficult. Sometimes we question ourselves because our assumptions are being challenged. And sometimes an article really is unnecessarily complicated.
Let’s not pretend otherwise.
Of course, questions about belonging and legitimacy become more complicated when we consider whose knowledge is recognised, who is encouraged to see themselves as an academic and who feels they must continually demonstrate their credibility.
Those are questions I’m interested in exploring through my research, rather than assuming I already know the answers.
For now, I’m trying not to diagnose myself every time I encounter a paragraph I have to read four times.
Although I reserve the right to complain about the paragraph.
A rather useful reminder about being a student
What I hadn’t quite anticipated was how much becoming a student again would make me reflect on my own work in academic development.
I’ve spent years talking about student engagement, inclusive learning environments, assessment, feedback and the importance of creating opportunities for students to take intellectual risks.
I believe in all of it.
But there’s something about finding yourself on the receiving end of those experiences that makes you pay attention differently.
I’ve noticed how reassuring it is when a tutor welcomes questions rather than expecting immediate answers. How much confidence it gives you when someone takes your half-formed idea seriously. And how valuable it is to be challenged without feeling that you’re being judged.
My professor’s enthusiastic response to my endless questioning is a good example.
Where I saw a collection of unresolved problems, he seemed to see the beginnings of doctoral thinking.
That hasn’t magically resolved my questions, of course.
If anything, I now have more of them.
But it has reminded me that being uncertain doesn’t necessarily mean you’re getting something wrong.
And perhaps that’s something worth remembering when we’re supporting our own students and colleagues.
So, am I a scholar yet?
I started this blog asking that question, and here I am, several years of professional experience and a Principal Fellowship later, still asking it.
You’d think I’d have settled the matter by now.
The slightly ridiculous thing is that I have no difficulty recognising the scholarship of the academics I work with. I can see their expertise, appreciate their contributions and encourage them to recognise the value of their practice.
Yet I’ve found myself wondering whether starting a doctorate somehow places me back at the beginning.
Which, when I think about it, makes absolutely no sense.
My professional knowledge hasn’t disappeared because I’ve become a doctoral student. I haven’t handed in my PFHEA certificate in exchange for a university library card.
I’m still the same person, with the same experience, responsibilities and occasionally questionable sense of humour.
I’m simply learning something new.
And perhaps the most interesting thing about this stage of my academic journey is recognising that I can be knowledgeable, capable and experienced while simultaneously being completely baffled by something I’ve just read.
Both are perfectly possible.
So, am I a scholar yet?
I think I might actually be one.
Just don’t ask me to explain my ontology before I’ve had my morning coffee.
And if anyone knows how to stop a Zotero reading list from multiplying overnight, I’m all ears.